Eli Manning
Football · New York Giants · Quarterback
Eli Manning's 2004 class is the core of his market: the Topps Chrome #205 base rookie is the flagship, and the on-card autographs (Playoff Contenders #131, the Bowman #111 auto, and SP Authentic #216) carry most of the upside. Base rookies from Topps and Bowman sell for little raw, and PSA 10 comps for them are thin or old. The auto and numbered-parallel comps are sparse, so treat the higher figures as indicative rather than current.
Prices are recent sales we found on Oct 8, 2026 and refresh weekly while people are looking. Check the sold prices before you buy.
9 key cards · Vote cards up or down to help rank them · As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you buy through the buttons below.
- Flagship rookie
2004 Topps Chrome #205 Rookie
The best-known Eli rookie. Chrome's shiny finish is prone to scratches, so clean PSA 10 copies are the ones buyers chase.
Raw and PSA 10 figures are from SportsCardsPro price-guide rows; PSA 10 sales run about 1 to 3 per year, so the comps are thin. PSA's own guide lists a PSA 10 at $375. Newest verified PSA 10 sale found was $515.
$74.99
raw, recent sale
PSA 10 $546
Top sale $515
- Flagship rookie
2004 Topps #350 Rookie
Topps Series 1 base rookie, the main Topps card for his first season.
No recent raw or PSA 10 sold comp verified. Newest graded sale found was a PSA 9 at $44.99 in Aug 2026; PSA 7s sold for about $6 to $30 in 2025.
$44.99
top recent sale
- Flagship rookie
2004 Bowman #111 Rookie
Bowman's base rookie is the other mainstream rookie card for his class and is widely collected in graded form.
Raw last sale $9.25 per Sports Card Investor, with recent eBay raw sales around $8 to $15. Recent PSA 9 sales run about $20 to $45 (Jul to Aug 2026). No PSA 10 sold comp verified.
$9.25
raw, recent sale
Top sale $62.99
- 1st Bowman / prospect
2004 Topps Chrome Premiere Prospects #PP5 Rookie
A prospect-insert version of his rookie year that collectors buy alongside the base Chrome card.
Recent PSA 10 sales range from about $122 to $255 across mid-2025 to Feb 2026 (4 to 5 sales). No recent raw sale found.
$203
PSA 10, recent sale
Top sale $255
- Autograph
2004 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto #131
The classic rookie autograph card from his class. Foil-sticker-era Rookie Ticket autos are among the most sought-after for Eli.
Thin market. Sales from 2021 to Oct 2025 include a $999.99 listing (grade not stated) and a PSA 7 at $770. Print run announced at 372 copies, not numbered on card.
$1,000
top recent sale
- Autograph
2004 Bowman #111 Rookie Auto
Bowman's on-card autograph version of the #111 rookie, a lower-cost way to own a signed Eli rookie.
Sold auto comps run about $200 to $350 across 2021 to Mar 2026, with grades mostly not stated. No verified PSA 10 sold comp.
$350
top recent sale
- Autograph
2004 SP Authentic Rookie Authentics Patch Auto #216 /299
A numbered, on-card autograph with a jersey swatch that many collectors name as his top investment-grade rookie.
No recent sold comps found. Only asking prices appeared in searches, so no price is listed.
—
no recent sale found
- Numbered parallel
2004 Topps Chrome Black Refractor #205 /100
The rarest version of his Topps Chrome rookie, with a 100-copy print run.
Only one PSA 10 sale found, from April 2019 at $1,625, which is old. No recent comps found.
$1,625
top recent sale
- Numbered parallel
2004 Topps Chrome Gold X-Fractor #205 /279
A numbered Chrome parallel of his rookie, sought by collectors building a full Chrome run.
Thin market. Last raw sale found was $302 in Nov 2024. No recent PSA 10 comp found.
$302
raw, recent sale