Home › Football › Jonathan Taylor
Jonathan Taylor
Football · Indianapolis Colts
Playing since 2020
- Indianapolis Colts 2020–
Taylor's 2020 Panini Prizm #332 rookie is the everyday card most buyers want, and its PSA 10 copies sell for roughly $20 to $45. The bigger money is in his rookie autographs: the Prizm Rookie Autographs (base auto, about $300 PSA 10 in April 2026), the Select Rookie Signatures /99 auto (a $350 PSA 10 in July 2026), and the National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto /99. Most of the top-end comps are older or thin, so treat the high-end numbers as indicative rather than current.
Prices are recent sales we found on Oct 14, 2026 and refresh weekly while people are looking. Check the sold prices before you buy.
13 key cards · Vote cards up or down to help rank them · As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you buy through the buttons and listings below.
- Flagship rookie
2020 Panini Prizm #332 Rookie (Base)
His main flagship rookie card from the 2020 Prizm set, the one most collectors start with.
Raw sales about $1.99 to $3.94 (Jan-Feb 2026). PSA 10 sales about $21 to $45 (Jan-Feb 2026). Recent comps.
$2.50
raw, recent sale
PSA 10 $36.00
- Flagship rookie
2020 Panini Prizm #332 Black & White Checker /(SSP) Rookie
A rare, short-print color parallel of the Prizm rookie that is one of the most sought-after versions of the base card.
Thin market. Last PSA 10 sale about $340 (older, 2024 range). A listing near $1.5K is asking-price data, not a sold price.
$340
PSA 10, recent sale
Top sale $1,500
- Flagship rookie
2020 Donruss Optic #167 Rated Rookie
His Donruss Optic rated rookie base, a flagship rookie that collectors also chase.
Thin market. PSA 9 sales of about $2 to $26 (2022-2023). No recent PSA 10 sold comps found.
$26.00
top recent sale
- 1st Bowman / prospect
2020 Panini Prizm Draft Picks #106 Rookie (Pink Pulsar)
A prospect card from his college draft-era Prizm Draft Picks set, a prospect card that buyers track.
Silver base raw sales about $1 to $3 (2026). PSA 10 Pink Pulsar sales of $28.99 (April 2026) and $29.99 (Nov 2025). Recent comps.
$2.00
raw, recent sale
PSA 10 $29.00
- Autograph
2020 Panini Prizm #332 Rookie Autographs (Base Auto)
The on-card autograph version of his Prizm rookie, the main rookie auto for most buyers.
Raw last sale $70 (May 2026). PSA 10 last sale $300 (April 2026). Thin, few sales.
$70.00
raw, recent sale
PSA 10 $300
- Autograph
2020 Panini Prizm #332 Rookie Autographs Gold /10
The top-end Prizm rookie auto, numbered to 10 with gold trim. It is considered his grail rookie card.
Very thin market. A $8,262 sale is cited in a CGC market guide with no date. Another source reports a far higher figure that I could not verify, so this is unconfirmed.
$8,262
top recent sale
- Autograph
2020 Panini Select Rookie Signatures Prizm /99 (#JTA)
A numbered on-card rookie auto from Select with a Silver Prizm finish, a well-regarded auto card for him.
PSA 10 sales of $350 (July 2026), $202.50 (Dec 2025), and $227.50 (2023). Thin market.
$350
PSA 10, recent sale
Top sale $228
- Autograph
2020 Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto /99 #172
One of the most popular higher-end rookie cards for him, a numbered-to-99 rookie patch auto.
Raw sales of about $228 to $350 (2024-Oct 2025). No recent PSA 10 sold comps found. Older comps.
$350
raw, recent sale
- Autograph
2020 Panini National Treasures NFL Shield Patch Auto /1
A 1-of-1 rookie NFL shield patch auto, the single top-selling card of his rookie cards.
1/1 card. A $7,000 sale is reported in an older article (around 2021), with no recent sold comp found.
$7,000
top recent sale
- Autograph
2020 Panini Immaculate Premium Patch Rookie Auto Gold /25 (#PPR-JTA)
A low-numbered rookie patch auto from Immaculate, a premium rookie auto.
One raw sale of $115 (January 2025). Thin, older comps.
$115
raw, recent sale
- Autograph
2020 Panini One Rookie Patch Auto /199 #18
A low-cost rookie patch auto that still draws interest from rookie-auto buyers.
Recent sales of about $82 to $128 (Oct 2025-April 2026). Ungraded listings. Most recent sale is $128 (April 2026).
$128
raw, recent sale
- Numbered parallel
2020 Donruss Optic Elite Series Rookies Gold /10 (#ESR-JT)
A numbered (/10) gold parallel of his Optic rookie, a short-print non-auto card.
Raw sales of $68 (Nov 2025), $74.99 (2024), $100 (2022), $103 (2024). Thin market.
$68.00
raw, recent sale
Top sale $103
- Numbered parallel
2020 Donruss Optic #167 Blue /179 Rated Rookie
A numbered Blue parallel of his Optic rated rookie, a non-auto numbered parallel.
One PSA 10 sale of $100 (Nov 2024). Thin market, older comps.
$100
PSA 10, recent sale