Home › Football › O. J. Simpson
O. J. Simpson
Football · Buffalo Bills · Running back
Simpson's cards are anchored by his 1970 Topps #90, the card the hobby treats as his true rookie. Raw copies are hard to price from recent sold data, while PSA 9 copies have sold for roughly $4,300 to $6,700 through 2026 and no PSA 10 has a recent sold comp. Because the card comes in few top grades, most buyers hunt PSA 9s or signed copies, and the market for his other cards is thin.
Prices are recent sales we found on Oct 8, 2026 and refresh weekly while people are looking. Check the sold prices before you buy.
8 key cards · Vote cards up or down to help rank them · As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you buy through the buttons below.
- Flagship rookie
1970 Topps Football #90 O.J. Simpson (RC)
The card PSA calls the only recognized rookie card of Simpson, and the centerpiece of any Bills or 1970s football collection.
Recent sold PSA 9 comps run about $4,300 to $6,700 (eBay and auction results, newest Aug 2026); PSA 10 shows zero sold comps. Clean raw sold comps were not found, so raw is left blank.
$6,670
top recent sale
- Autograph
1970 Topps #90 O.J. Simpson Signed Rookie (PSA/DNA or BAS auto)
A signed version of the key rookie card, with the signature graded as the main value driver.
Only one sold comp found: an auction result of $1,152 with a PSA-graded autograph 10; sale date not shown. Other signed copies on dealer sites are asking prices, not sold.
$1,152
PSA 10, recent sale
- Autograph
1995 Signature Rookies The Juice #J3 O.J. Simpson Autograph
A numbered trial-era autograph card, sought by collectors of his signed material.
Thin market: I found only asking prices, no recent sold comps.
—
no recent sale found
- Key insert / SSP
1970 Topps Super #24 O.J. Simpson (RC)
The only card in the 1970 Topps Super set with a yellow background, so it draws a niche following alongside the base rookie.
No recent sold comps found; the listings I saw were still open or asking.
—
no recent sale found
- Key insert / SSP
1970 Kellogg's 3-D Super Stars #48 O.J. Simpson (RC)
A 3-D rookie-year card from the 1970 Kellogg's set, often bought as an alternative to the Topps rookie.
Recent sold PSA 7 comps of about $47 to $75 (2024 to 2025); no PSA 10 sold comps and no recent raw sold comps.
$75.00
top recent sale
- Pre-rookie / overseas
1969 Glendale Stamps #48 O.J. Simpson (pre-rookie)
The pre-rookie stamp, which predates his Topps rookie by a year and is valued by early-football collectors.
No recent sold comps found; the market is thin.
—
no recent sale found
- Other
1974 Topps #1 O.J. Simpson
Simpson's base card in the 1974 set's opening slot, a modest collectible for Bills and set-builder buyers.
Six ungraded sold comps from 2026 range from about $4.78 to $9.99; no PSA 10 sold comps.
$7.48
raw, recent sale
- Other
1972 Topps #160 O.J. Simpson (HOF)
A Hall of Fame base card that set builders and Bills fans seek in higher grades.
PSA 8 sold roughly $56 to $89 across 2026 comps; raw sold comps were not clearly found.
$89.00
top recent sale